Choosing a Host Agency: Big Host vs. Boutique Agency (From an Agency Owner)

The When You Wish Travel advisor team posing together in matching light blue outfits
The quick answer

When you’re choosing a host agency, a big host can work well if you already have clients, want the highest possible commission split and are comfortable figuring things out on your own. If you want a mentor you can actually reach, a team that knows your name and support while you grow, a boutique agency is usually the better fit.

I’ve been on both sides of this. I started at a large host agency, tried a smaller one, and then built my own. Here’s what I’ve learned, so you can choose the right home for your travel business.

Big host agency
Higher advertised splits, bigger supplier buy-ins, support mostly by email
Boutique agency
Direct access to the owner, mentorship, a smaller team that knows you
When You Wish Travel
About 30 advisors across the US, 70% to 85% commission
Cost to join us
$197 one-time setup, then $35 per month

How I Got Here

I started in travel in 2016 with a large host agency. Back then there was no CRM, no way of tracking commissions, and commissions went unpaid. It was a mess.

To be fair, the big hosts have grown up since then. Most of them now have a CRM, commission tracking and the other common business practices in place.

Later I tried to mesh into a second agency, a boutique agency this time, and it wasn’t the right fit. I’ve always been more of an entrepreneur and a leader, so in January 2020 I started When You Wish Travel. I wanted to put my skills to work, mentor agents, find my people and work with others who share a love of travel.

What Big Host Agencies Do Well

Big hosts have real strengths, and they’re worth knowing before you decide:

  • Higher commission splits. Many big hosts advertise splits higher than a boutique agency starts with.
  • Bigger buy-ins with suppliers. Their size can mean higher commission levels with cruise lines and other suppliers.
  • Established systems. Booking tools, CRMs and commission tracking are usually built out.

If you’re an experienced advisor with a steady client base and you like working independently, a big host may give you exactly what you need.

Where Big Host Agencies Can Fall Short

The tradeoff is that a big host can be a lonely place.

  • You may not even know who’s in charge. A lot of the time, you don’t know who the boss is or who to go to when you need an answer.
  • Getting help from the top isn’t quick. You can’t text or call the person in charge. You send an email and wait days, sometimes weeks, for an answer.
  • There’s often no mentor. In a small agency you can ask someone your everyday questions. At a big host you usually do the research yourself and trust your findings.
  • It’s easy to feel like a small fish in a big pond. You can be surrounded by thousands of advisors and still feel alone in a crowded room.

For a newer advisor, that can mean slower bookings, more second-guessing and a lot of time spent looking for answers instead of planning trips.

Big Host vs. Boutique Agency: Side by Side

big host agency
Big Host Agency
Often higher advertised commission splits and bigger supplier buy-ins. Support usually comes through email or a help desk, and training is mostly self-guided.
Best for: Experienced advisors with an established client base who prefer to work on their own
boutique agency
Boutique Agency
A smaller team, direct access to the owner and mentorship from someone who knows your business. Splits may start lower and grow as you grow.
Best for: New advisors, career changers and anyone who wants a team and a mentor they can reach

The Commission Split Question: 90% of 0 Is Still 0

Higher commission splits are the most common way agencies recruit new advisors. And yes, you can earn a higher split at a big host. But if you don’t have the support to find clients and book them with confidence, 90% of 0 is still 0.

I believe in transparency, so here is exactly how it works at When You Wish Travel. We offer two contract options:

  • Individual Contract: starts at 70% and moves up based on sales.
  • Company Contract: requires your own LLC and EIN, and starts at 80%.
  • Both contracts have the option to increase to 85% based on sales.

To join, there’s a one-time $197 account setup fee and a $35 monthly agency systems fee. That covers your agency email, CRM, and the tools used to manage bookings and clients.

We may not have the biggest supplier buy-ins yet, but we’re climbing the ranks with cruise suppliers year by year.

What It Looks Like When Your Agency Actually Knows You

This is the part I care about most. Here’s what our advisors have access to:

  • Direct access to me. I’ve been in this industry for 10 years and have planned more than 1,000 vacations. If you have a question, you can text me.
  • A team of about 30 advisors across the US. You’re never alone in a crowded room. There’s always someone to chat with, compare notes with or celebrate a booking with.
  • Weekly check-ins. I check in with our advisors every Friday to see how things are going.
  • Mentorship and training. An onboarding course, training webinars and our Advisor Playbook, so you’re not guessing at how to plan a trip.
  • Website leads. Families who reach out through our website are shared with advisors who use our agency planning packages.
  • Planning packages and systems. Our planning packages, agency email and WishKeeperCRM, the CRM I designed for travel advisors.
  • Group chats and fam trips. Time to learn destinations together and get to know each other.

You’re an independent contractor, so you choose your schedule, decide how you grow your business and work with the clients you want to serve. We’re here to support you while you do it.

Which Type of Agency Is Right for You?

A big host agency may be a good fit if you:

  • Already have a steady base of clients
  • Want the highest possible split from day one
  • Are comfortable researching answers on your own

A boutique agency like ours may be a good fit if you:

  • Are new to travel or changing careers
  • Are already at a big host and feel lost or on your own
  • Want a mentor you can reach and a team that knows your name
  • Love planning Disney vacations, cruises and all-inclusive resorts for families
  • Live in the United States

Good to Know Before You Choose Any Agency

Whichever direction you lean, these questions will tell you a lot:

  • How fast can I reach the owner or a mentor? Ask what happens when you’re stuck on a booking.
  • How are commissions tracked and paid? I learned this one the hard way.
  • What are all the fees? Look past the split to setup fees, monthly fees and anything else you’ll pay.
  • How are leads handled? Ask whether the agency shares leads and what’s expected when you take one.
  • Can I talk to a current advisor? They’ll tell you what it’s really like.

Frequently Asked Questions

A host agency lets independent travel advisors book travel under its accreditation, supplier relationships and booking systems while they run their own business. Most advisors who are not starting their own accredited agency work under a host.

A big host agency usually has thousands of advisors, higher advertised commission splits and a lot of self-guided training. A boutique agency is smaller and often owner-led, so you get direct access to the owner, mentorship and a team that knows you by name.

Not always. A higher split only matters if you are booking trips. If you do not have the support to find clients and book them with confidence, 90% of 0 is still 0. Look at the support, training and leads that come with the split.

We offer two contracts. The Individual Contract starts at 70%. The Company Contract, for advisors with their own LLC and EIN, starts at 80%. Both can increase to 85% based on sales.

There is a one-time $197 account setup fee and a $35 monthly agency systems fee. These cover your agency email, CRM, and the tools used to manage bookings and clients.

No. You only need your own LLC and EIN for the Company Contract. The Individual Contract does not require one.

Yes. Advisors need to be located in the US. Our team is spread across the country.

Yes. Our advisors are independent contractors who set their own schedules, so this can work as a part-time business or a full-time career.

Let Us Help You Build Your Travel Business

If you’re looking for an agency where people actually know you, we’d love to hear from you. Watch Ashley’s short video, see how joining works and apply when you’re ready.

Picture of Ashley Flowers

Ashley Flowers

Ashley Flowers is the owner of When You Wish Travel and has been helping families plan vacations since 2016. A wife, mom, and frequent Disney traveler, she combines firsthand experience at Disney destinations, Universal Orlando, and aboard cruise ships with practical advice for busy families. She believes the best vacations leave room for both the must-do experiences and the little moments you’ll remember long after you’re home.

Picture of Sarah Barrette

Sarah Barrette

Sarah Barrette has loved travel since she was 15, with adventures spanning France, Panama, Hawaii, the Bahamas, Alaska, and the Southern Caribbean. After visiting Walt Disney World with her husband in 2018, she’s returned every year, including a special trip with their children. While Disney is her specialty, Sarah enjoys planning everything from adults-only retreats to family vacations, bringing personal experience and thoughtful attention to every trip.

Picture of Madison Fariss

Madison Fariss

Madison Fariss is a When You Wish Travel dream designer specializing in Disney destinations, Universal Studios, all-inclusive resorts and cruising. A mom of two toddlers in Western Kentucky, she heads back to the Disney parks year after year, whether she's on a cruise, hugging Minnie at Disneyland or park-hopping at Walt Disney World with a Mickey pretzel in hand. She loves taking the stress out of planning so families can focus on the magic.

Ashley Flowers

Ashley Flowers is the owner of When You Wish Travel and has been helping families plan vacations since 2016. A wife, mom, and frequent Disney traveler, she combines firsthand experience at Disney destinations, Universal Orlando, and aboard cruise ships with practical advice for busy families. She believes the best vacations leave room for both the must-do experiences and the little moments you’ll remember long after you’re home.